“I wish it need not have happened in my time,” said Frodo. “So do I,” said Gandalf, “and so do all who live to see such times. But that is not for them to decide. All we have to decide is what to do with the time that is given us.”
― J.R.R. Tolkien, The Fellowship of the Ring
The Time We Have
If you have read any of the books or watched any of the movies, The Lord of The Rings is a powerful saga. Yes, I said it—saga. Tolkien was masterful with the entirety of the story but what I find wondrous is that all the bits and pieces along the way are full of flavor and are stories in themselves. They are powerful all on their own.

The quote above is part of a brief conversation between Gandalf and Frodo. If you haven’t read the books or watched the movies, you may still appreciate its depth as it is rich with meaning whether in or out of the story.
These fifty-one words are all about humanity’s age old divide between those who seek power and those who seek to live the life they were meant to live.
The powerful, many times, feed off the destruction of their own making only to disrupt humanity to, well, gain more power. I’m in the camp that power based in love, compaaion and insight lifts humanity.
Each sentence in this quote is revealing. this is how I look at it.
Frodo says… I wish it need not have happened in my time
Although Frodo is a Hobbit, he expresses a very human feeling we all, at some time feel. Every so often this feeling results from a natural phenomenon like an earthquake or a hurricane, but most of the time, it results from man and his intentional actions. War would be a big one as would dehumanizing those who are not like us.
History is full of men who overreach to claim power and control. By doing so, those who seek to live their lives the best they can and how they see fit are whipped into colossal, turbulent waves. They get caught in the wake of the murky froth of the power-hungry and their dark and self-serving decisions.
Humanity and everything about how we live is dualistic. We have good, so there is bad; we have love, so there is hate; we have the rich, so we must have the poor, and so on. Power without love, compasion or insight exists to prey on the weak…the poor…or those deemed as unworthy.
What is imagined in the mind can become a reality.
The above neutral statement is easily corrupted when the cunning manipulator is searching for a “treasure” that benefits the few. If only those who sought power also sought good.
Gandalf follows his statement and says…So do I
These three words show empathy. The experienced and wise wizard has seen much in his long life, but it is with his experience that his empathy flows naturally. More importantly, it is soothing—it is healing.
He is reafirming in these three words. He offers, as all good teachers do, a broder view with what he says next.
…and so do all who live to see such times.
We search for answers — for perspective. As long as humans have roamed the planet they have, from time to time, created devatation. The wise teacher reminds young Frodo (and us too) that we are not alone.
But Gandalf goes on to say…But that is not for them to decide.
When we realize that most of us feel the same way, our imagination, too, may shape what is next. With the hard truth, Gandalf moves Frodo away from taking a turn into self-despair as self-despair is exactly what the powerful want from those they wish to control.
He helps Frodo to focus when he says,
…All we have to decide is what to do with the time that is given us.
When outside forces suffocate us, will we find the spark within us to take charge of our next step…and then the second step… and then…
Simply, we are not alone. We always have help. We always have hope. And with that, it is us who decide what to do with the time that is given us.
…you may also like, It’s All Created In the Mind
About E.G. Kardos
I am a fiction writer and the author of five books. My writing draws inspiration from the beauty surrounding us all—both in nature and in each other. Spirituality, friendship, love, and our connection to the universe inspire me to write. Here’s more about me and my books.
Latest Posts
- The Gloaming: When Day Meets Night and it is Spectacular
- Paulo Coelho and Small Miracles
- C.S. Lewis, Fairytales and You
- Writing Literary Fiction and What I’m Learning
- Symbols of Our Love Every Day and Mother’s Day
Most Viewed Posts
All Posts
